Mark B. Kilduff

Mark B. Kilduff is a seasoned trial attorney who brings firsthand knowledge of insurance company tactics to every case he handles. Having previously worked with the insurance industry, he knows exactly how insurers operate—and how to counter their strategies to protect his clients’ rights. 

Mark brings over 25 years of civil litigation experience to Rutter Mills, dedicated to advocating for individuals harmed by negligence and wrongdoing. Educated at the University of Virginia (B.A., 1991) and the University of Richmond School of Law (J.D., 1995), where he was a member of the Richmond Law Review, he’s a seasoned trial lawyer with a formidable record. With a deep understanding of both defense strategies and plaintiff needs, Mark approaches every case strategically. He is committed to delivering thoughtful, client-centered representation—bringing tenacity in negotiation and excellence in the courtroom.

Before transitioning to plaintiff advocacy, Mark built a high-profile career defending corporations and insurance carriers in complex civil litigation. As a partner at major insurance defense firms, he managed hundreds of cases involving:

• Insurance disputes

• Premises and premises liability

• Civil litigation

This background granted him deep insight into how insurers operate—what they fear, where they cut corners, how they defend, and when they capitulate. By knowing the defense playbook intimately—how evidence is evaluated, defense experts are deployed, and liability is minimized—Mark is uniquely positioned to anticipate and counter those strategies. That experience is invaluable to plaintiffs: he understands what defenses are weak, what paper trail to demand, and how to construct a case insurers can’t easily dismiss.

Mark’s pivot to representing injury victims is fueled by a steadfast commitment to fairness and an empathetic understanding of clients’ struggles. These aren’t just empty words—they’re reflections of Mark’s case philosophy: real people coping with pain, loss, and uncertainty deserve more than legal representation—they deserve a trusted ally who sees and hears them. That’s precisely what Mark delivers. He doesn’t just pursue compensation; he nurtures trust and instills hope.

When life’s unexpected injuries disrupt your world, you don’t just need legal help—you need someone who knows what the other side is thinking, how to level the playing field, and how to fight for the compensation you deserve, all while treating you with kindness and respect.

Mark B. Kilduff and Rutter Mills Personal Injury Law Firm deliver that rare combination. With empathy, experience, and a proven record of success, he stands ready to guide and fight for you on the path to fair recovery.