I am beyond happy with my experience working with Rutter Mills. Rutter Mills was responsive throughout the entire journey and worked diligently on my behalf, making the process worry and stress free. I cannot recommend this company enough.
The Hidden Injury That Nearly Ended a Navy Career
A serious car accident does more than derail your day. In some cases, it can change your life. When that happens, a serious car accident lawyer can help put things right.
Key Takeaways from this Article:
- Not every serious car accident injury is immediately obvious.
- Following your treatment plan is critical.
- Early insurance settlement offers may not account for future diagnoses.
The Car Accident That Changed Everything
When an active-duty U.S. Naval officer left for work one January morning in 2025, he had no idea that his life was about to change. As he neared the Joint Expeditionary Base Little Creek Fort-Story, a car exited a parking lot in front of him.
The crash happened too quickly for him to hit the brakes.
His car rolled three times, coming to a stop facing oncoming traffic. The airbags deployed, and the windshield shattered. The former firefighter and seasoned servicemember froze in the moment, as the crash unfolded around him.
In his own words:
“I’ve been in some crazy situations throughout my life, especially in the military. I’ve been in floods, fires, been shot at, you name it. All of the training that I’ve had in my career told me to stay in the car and not move. But adrenaline was pumping very high. I got out of the car, had to climb through the windshield because my door wouldn’t open. I actually grabbed my own med bag out of the car in case someone needed help … and then realized: ‘I’m the one that’s hurt.'”
A Life-Changing Diagnosis
At the hospital, he was diagnosed with a concussion, internal bruising, and whiplash—and considered himself lucky.
“I was sore, but I was alive. The fact that I didn’t leave my wife alone and I’m still here was a miracle.”
As he began his prescribed physical therapy, however, the soreness not only persisted, but grew worse.
“They found out I had a post-traumatic Chiari alformation. It’s where the back of your brain, your cerebellum, starts pushing into your spinal column, which can happen from spinal trauma.”
From Active Duty to LIMDU
Before the accident, the servicemember was up for a promotion to Chief, a goal he had worked toward for years. All of that was now at risk, as the sailor was placed on Limited Medical Duty (LIMDU).
Navy Limited Medical Duty is a temporary duty status for sailors who have a medical condition that prevents them from performing their normal duties. During LIMDU, the Navy provides time for treatment and recovery while determining whether the service member can return to full duty or requires further evaluation.
He thought that the insurance company would take care of things, until they made an offer that wouldn’t even cover his medical bills. With his family’s future and his career at stake, our client knew he needed help to prevent someone else’s mistake from ruining his future.
That’s when he called Rutter Mills.
Negotiating a Higher Settlement for a Life-Changing Injury
Trial attorney Denise Whitelaw took the case. Right away, she knew the mission was to ensure the claim and the recovery reflected the injury the sailor actually suffered, not just the ones diagnosed in the emergency room.
Medical records explained the injury, but they couldn’t fully capture what it had taken from the sailor. They didn’t highlight the uncertainty surrounding his military career, the promotion that was suddenly in jeopardy, or the possibility of a medical discharge.
To help paint that complete picture, Denise encouraged him to write an impact statement describing how the crash had changed his life:
“These injuries have led to complex structural and neurological complications that restrict my mobility and cause chronic, radiating pain. After dedicating over 12 years to the United States Navy, this completely avoidable accident—which was caused solely by the negligence of the other driver and for which I was not found at fault—has placed my career, my livelihood, and my long-term future at severe risk.”
The Final Outcome: $72,500 Settlement
The insurance companies increased their offers, but they still failed to account for the significant impact of his injuries and uncertain military future. Our team continued negotiating until the settlement reflected the severity of his injuries and the value of his claim.
The case settled for $72,500.
After picking up his check at our office in Norfolk, our client had this to say:
“Everything was fantastic. The amount I got was fantastic. I want to put this all behind me, but I am very, very satisfied. Thank you, Rutter Mills!”
Not Every Serious Injury Is Immediately Obvious
It wasn’t until the sailor noticed worsening pain during physical therapy that the post-traumatic Chiari malformation was discovered. His experience highlights an important reality after many car accidents: not every serious injury is immediately apparent.
If he had skipped physical therapy or ignored his lingering pain, the post-traumatic Chiari malformation may have gone undiagnosed much longer. Instead, continuing treatment gave his physical therapist the opportunity to recognize that something more serious was causing his symptoms.
Had he quickly accepted a settlement offer, he would not have received sufficient compensation for his injuries, treatment, lost wages, or pain and suffering.
Why Following Your Treatment Plan Matters
After a car accident, it’s important to continue following your doctor’s recommendations, even if your symptoms seem manageable at first.
Attending follow-up appointments allows your healthcare providers to monitor your recovery and identify conditions that may not have been visible during your initial evaluation.
If your pain changes, worsens, or new symptoms develop, tell your doctor as soon as possible rather than assuming they’re a normal part of healing.
In many cases, medical experts such as neurologists, orthopedic physicians, or spine specialists uncover injuries that emergency room physicians could not reasonably diagnose immediately after the crash.
Common Hidden Injuries After a Car Accident
Many injuries may not appear during an emergency room visit, but instead become more noticeable in the days or weeks following a crash. Adrenaline can temporarily mask pain, inflammation can develop over time, and some injuries require follow-up imaging or specialist evaluations before they can be accurately diagnosed.
Some of the most common delayed or hidden injuries include:
- Concussions and traumatic brain injuries: Headaches, dizziness, memory problems, sensitivity to light, and difficulty concentrating may not appear immediately after a collision.
- Herniated or bulging discs: Damage to the spine can cause pain, numbness, tingling, or weakness that develops gradually as swelling increases.
- Spinal cord injuries: Even when a spinal cord injury isn’t immediately obvious, delayed symptoms such as numbness, coordination problems, or loss of strength should be evaluated promptly.
- Ligament and tendon damage: Soft tissue injuries, including tears and severe sprains, may initially feel like ordinary soreness before becoming significantly more painful.
- Internal bleeding: Abdominal pain, dizziness, deep bruising, or fainting after a crash may indicate internal injuries that require emergency medical attention.
- Nerve injuries: Tingling, burning sensations, weakness, or reduced sensation in the arms or legs can signal damage to nerves affected by the collision.
- Emotional trauma: Anxiety, depression, post-traumatic stress, sleep disturbances, and a fear of driving may develop in the days or weeks following a serious collision.
When Should You Contact a Lawyer?
You don’t have to know the full extent of your injuries before speaking with a car accident lawyer. As the sailor’s case demonstrates, many serious injuries become apparent only after additional treatment or testing. An attorney can help ensure your claim reflects your evolving medical condition, and isn’t resolved before the full impact of your injuries is understood.
At Rutter Mills, we work with your medical providers, gather the evidence needed to document your losses, and fight for compensation that reflects the full impact of your injuries.
Call or text (757) 777-7777 anytime to discuss your legal options. We’re here to help, 24/7.
Legacy
0
+
Years Helping Injury Victims
Locations
0
Convenient Locations in Hampton Roads
Strength
0
+
Team Members Ready to Help
Enjoy this 60 second look at What Matters Most
Real Google Reviews
See what our clients say about their experience at Rutter Mills.
Workers Compensation
If you’ve been injured on the job, workers’ compensation insurance may entitle you to critical assistance like medical treatment, lost wages, and more. But insurance companies will put up an aggressive fight to resist paying you the compensation you need and deserve. Rutter Mills can help get you the money you deserve.
