The Appeals Process: What Happens After a Denial
Receiving a denial can be discouraging, but it doesn’t mean your case is over. In fact, many people who ultimately receive Social Security Disability benefits are approved only after filing an appeal. Rather than starting over with a new application, appealing allows you to preserve your filing date and continue building your case. At Rutter Mills, we represent clients at every stage of the appeals process.
Reconsideration
The first step after a denial is usually requesting reconsideration. We review the reasons your claim was denied, identify any missing medical evidence or documentation, and submit a stronger, more complete case on your behalf. Our goal is to address the issues that led to the initial denial instead of simply resubmitting the same information.
Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) Hearing
If your claim is denied again, you may request a hearing before an Administrative Law Judge. This is often the stage where representation can make the biggest difference. In fiscal year 2024, approximately 51% of disability claims decided by an ALJ resulted in an award of benefits, making a hearing a significantly stronger opportunity than starting over with a new application.
Before your hearing, we gather updated medical records, prepare you for the questions you may be asked, develop legal arguments that support your claim, and represent you before the judge. Our attorneys work to present the strongest possible case for why you meet Social Security’s disability requirements.
Appeals Council Review
If the Administrative Law Judge denies your claim, you may request a review by the Social Security Appeals Council. We evaluate whether the judge made legal or procedural errors, prepare the written arguments supporting your appeal, and submit any additional information permitted under the rules.
Federal Court
If necessary, your case can be appealed to federal court. This stage focuses on whether the Social Security Administration correctly applied the law and followed proper procedures. Our attorneys can evaluate whether a federal appeal is appropriate and continue advocating for your rights throughout the process.
Don’t Go It Alone
Don’t assume a denial is the end of your claim. The sooner you speak with an experienced Social Security disability attorney, the sooner you can begin building a stronger case for the benefits you’ve earned.